I'm a bit late to the game, but here are my favorite games so far:
Spyro 1-3
Crash Bandicoot 1,2, & 3
Star Wars Battlefront (liked having the ability to control a small unit in the second one)
Abes Odyssey
Gears of War
Dark Forces
Hart of Darkness
Rocket League
Journey (my favorite by far)
Super Mario
Pokemon (blue, red, and yellow)
Kirby
Tower Fall (a great game to have friends over to play)
and of course South Park: The Stick of Truth
and others if I can think of them
Spyro 1-3
Crash Bandicoot 1,2, & 3
Star Wars Battlefront (liked having the ability to control a small unit in the second one)
Abes Odyssey
Gears of War
Dark Forces
Hart of Darkness
Rocket League
Journey (my favorite by far)
Super Mario
Pokemon (blue, red, and yellow)
Kirby
Tower Fall (a great game to have friends over to play)
and of course South Park: The Stick of Truth
and others if I can think of them
If you wanna find some quality friends you have to wade through all the dicks first - Eric Cartman